[bisq-network/proposals] Listing fee policy - step 1 (general) (#35)

[Harry MacFinned]

In answer to @cbeams.

1. I may be wrong, but I heard that Manfred targeted v0.7.2 released for this monday august 20th. (Has it changed ?)
... if this is the case, this will let today + tomorrow for open PR submitters to read the comment in their asset PR (... if they do it) and to react. This is very short notice (and maybe a bit rude).
Maybe it will be more diplomatic not to appear to put them back to the wall and simply tell them that their PR will not be treated for v0.7.2 (too late), and also that rules have changed.

2. Due also to the v0.7.2 release being due very shortly, some contributors/small+big stakeholders being probably quite busy, have even not told their opinions about this proposal. I'm not even sure they know this proposal is running. Can something be decided so fast without their opinion/vote being known ?

3. What is '1 BTC listing fee' ? it's 1 BTC forever, for one release, for 2018, for one year ?

4. ok for mentionning the fees are not refundable. But maybe the fees should also be, for a period of time, and modifiable.

4. as @manfredkarrer mentionned
> There might be legal implications, which should be thought out well.

Have we fully taken the possible legal implications in consideration ? (If yes, fine).

5. Which BTC address will be used ? the donation address as suggested by Manfred ? Or better not to mix donations and charges ? 

6. I will browse thru the asset list to point which assets have not been traded in the past 4 months. And pass the list to @manfredkarrer .If it's not necessary please tell me.
(I didn't make the count yet, but there will be probably some altcoins with trades in the past 4 months, but although not profitable for Bisq.)

7. I had in mind that of course we may charge BTCs, but maybe we could also propose alternatives means.

I submitted this proposal on august 14th, after a 5 lines discussion with Manfred on slack on august 11th.
In my mind I didn't imagine we would apply it for v0.7.2 which was targeted for mid-en august.

I fully agree that there is a need to change the actual listing fee policy, but imo we should take the time necessary for that.
Listing fee policy was unchanged for months/years, if it takes us some days now, this wouldn't hurt.


-- 
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
https://github.com/bisq-network/proposals/issues/35#issuecomment-414040255
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.bisq.network/pipermail/bisq-github/attachments/20180818/08e73fcf/attachment.html>