[bisq-network/support] Reimbursement for trades SIUT5I, morhk, XFKeX, YFNLU (#822)

[SecretiveBat]

@huey735 and @refund-agent2 I have strong suspicions that @Wrecktangl3 is not being truthful with this request and deliberately misleading the DAO.

Please can DAO check to see if @Wrecktangl3 did in fact make payment for all the above 4 trades? It should be possible to check out trade ID mediation and arbitration tickets to see if payment was in fact made? Also, mediators could reopen mediation tickets with @Wrecktangl3's counterparties to confirm the version of events.

Issue #726 was poorly referenced. Has a genuine bug has been established?

I think refunds in cases like this lead the way to users potentially trying to scam the DAO either by self-trading or by trying to claim what they know they are not entitled to as a result of their own failings.

Hypothetically a scammer could do the following: 

- Take multiple trades on Bisq to buy BTC
- Not make fiat payment for any trades
- Post a vague issue on GitHub with key information missing
- Wait a period of time until a refund agent has been made 
- Raise a request to be compensated by the DAO for the security deposit (paid) and trading amounts (not paid)

Taking it a step further a scammer could then complete self trades with themselves to get paid out twice and not lose security deposit.

DAO should be careful when refunding users that provide incomplete and miss-leading information. There should be an onus on users to provide all the necessary evidence that what they said occurred did actually occur.

@Wrecktangl3 I think you should not be paid out at all for the trades due to my above concerns. I would review my opinion if you can provide the required evidence of your version of events.

-- 
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
https://github.com/bisq-network/support/issues/822#issuecomment-789314424
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.bisq.network/pipermail/bisq-github/attachments/20210302/5a02d89d/attachment.htm>