[bisq-network/bisq] Improve user experience once mediation has been accepted by both parties (#5546)

pazza notifications at github.com
Mon May 31 21:59:32 CEST 2021


<!--
   SUPPORT REQUESTS: This is for reporting bugs in the Bisq app.
   If you have a support request, please join #support on Bisq's
   Keybase team over at https://keybase.io/team/Bisq
-->

### Description

When mediation for a given trade is accepted by both parties the trade moves from 'open trades' to 'history' and the payout transaction ID is broadcast.

This is how it should be but the user experience could be achieved by keeping the trade in 'open trades' for longer and give the user the option to withdraw funds to Bisq wallet or external wallet. This would add an additional step that is the same as what happens currently when trades in 'open trades' are successfully completed ie, the user is notified and then they make the choice to keep funds in Bisq wallet or withdraw them. This would improve the user experience consistency.


#### Version

v 1.6.5

### Steps to reproduce

**From the perspective of 'Trader 1 (initial trader to accept mediation)'**

A trade goes to mediation.

1. Trader 1 accepts mediation proposal.
2. Trader 2 accepts mediation proposal.

Trader 1 is not informed mediation has been accepted, there is no notification. Next time they log in the trade will have moved from open trades to history and the broadcast payout tx id will hopefully have been paid out. Trader 1 will need to check funds > transactions to see the status of the trade.

**From the perspective of 'Trader 2 (second trader to accept mediation)'**

A trade goes to mediation.

1. Trader 1 accepts mediation proposal.
2. Trader 2 accepts mediation proposal.

Trader 2 is not informed mediation has been accepted, there is no notification. The trade will have moved from open trades to history and the payout tx id will be broadcast.


### Expected behaviour

**From the perspective of 'Trader 1 (initial trader to accept mediation)'**

A trade goes to mediation.

1. Trader 1 accepts mediation proposal.
2. Trader 2 accepts mediation proposal.

Trader 1 is not informed mediation has been accepted, there is a notification. The mediated trade will still be in open trades and the Trader 1 will have the option to keep the funds in their Bisq wallet or withdraw to an external wallet. The trade will then move to history.

**From the perspective of 'Trader 2 (second trader to accept mediation)'**

A trade goes to mediation.

1. Trader 1 accepts mediation proposal.
2. Trader 2 accepts mediation proposal.

Trader 2 is informed mediation has been accepted, by a notification. The trade will still be in open trades and Trader 2 will have the option to keep the funds in their Bisq wallet or withdraw to an external wallet.  The trade will then move to history.


-- 
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
https://github.com/bisq-network/bisq/issues/5546
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.bisq.network/pipermail/bisq-github/attachments/20210531/760d1fef/attachment-0001.htm>


More information about the bisq-github mailing list