[bisq-network/bisq] Bisq 2 social trading concept (Discussion #6011)

[chimp1984]

Great thanks! Looks great!

Select Contract Type and Trader type:
When we have multiple trade protocols, can the user create multiple profiles?

Generate Username:
i think insereting a pubkeyhash could be left for advanced options (a user need to export it from a bisq app and then import to another bisq app - i dont see another use case like adding a profile from other platforms). 
The user name is autogenerated from the pubkey. Same like icon.
So maybe that can reduce that to  "change" use case as only thing the user can do here.

Create trading profile:
What if the user does not want yet to trade? I guess we offer a skip button so the user can go "read only" mode as well.

Rating at the end:
I am still not sure how we could add user rating in a privacy protecting and verifyable/decentralized way. Maybe there are some ways but as long its not clear, better to not consider that a final feature. Decentralized reputation is a hard problem and I am not aware of a generic solution.
The problem is that anyone could attach those ratings to oneself (by code change). To verify it we would need the other peer to publish some proof, but all that would reveal who traded with whom.
I consider also to not publish trade statistics in Bisq 2 for similar reasons. We could still use a feedback to the peer alone (not to the network). 

Regarding wording/terms:
I am not english native speaker so I cannot judge well what would fit best. So my 5 cents should be seen in that context. Leave it to native speaker to decide on the terminology.
- Reputable trader: It sounds to me a bit "technical"/unusual. I am not sure if we should use "Trusted sellers" as we might not limit to seller role and we should not communicate wrong security by using "trusted". Maybe something more neutral but which still shows to newbies that those traders are kind of recommended. Something like "Pro-trader" or "Onboarding-buddy" but both do not sound good.... Or we invent a term maybe realted to Bisq? Some play with "etiquette" and Bisq? Bisq traders with etiquette - Bisquette seems to be some cookie ;-). Maybe someone else has better ideas ;-)

- Reputable trading: What about "Social trading"?





-- 
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
https://github.com/bisq-network/bisq/discussions/6011#discussioncomment-2432720
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.

Message ID: <bisq-network/bisq/repo-discussions/6011/comments/2432720 at github.com>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.bisq.network/pipermail/bisq-github/attachments/20220324/a71f4569/attachment.htm>